This marks Peters' return to the Broadway musical stage after the 2011 revival of Follies, and it's been even longer for Garber; his last Broadway musical was Damn Yankees in 1994. “When I was young, that was all I did. And then I stopped singing for a while, and then when I came back to singing, it’s like my muscles atrophied,” says Garber. “You have to keep it up.”
But the true highlight came when Peters demonstrated the exercise she does with the show’s ensemble each night. Watch how many push-ups she can do in the video above!