Playbill.com reported on the couple's engagement in September last year. "Yes, it's true, we are engaged," Hershberg told Playbill. "I can say we're very, very happy, and our cherished family pet, Vito the robotic vacuum cleaner, is practically buzzing with excitement."
Hershberg was also on Broadway in Baby It's You! and Fontana was last seen on Broadway in Act One. The couple performed together in A Very Broadway Valentine's Day concert at 54 Below. Click here for the Playbill Playlist from the cast, in which they picked their favorite love songs.