Lee, whose Broadway credits include Spring Awakening and Spider-Man Turn Off the Dark, sang Lady Gaga's "You and I" and received votes of support from Kesha and Ludacris, while Brad Paisley voted no.
After Paisley said "the Broadway style didn't quite fit" the "bluesiness" of the song, host Josh Groban said, "I would do a Broadway duet with you right now, just to piss Brad off."
Lee will compete again in the following round.
Watch Lee perform below.