Directed by Tim Drucker with musical direction by Scott Ethier, the concert featured Becca Ayers (Dogfight), Nick Cearley (The Skivvies, All Shook Up), James Donegan (Forbidden Broadway), Ann Harada (Cinderella), Nathan Johnson, Amy Rutberg, George Salazar (Godspell), Hollis Scarborough and Joanna Young (The Drowsy Chaperone).
Here's how the concert was described: "Thirteen years have passed since the fateful day Dan Acquisto and Sammy Buck sat down in a dusky midtown office at a piano once owned by Stephen Sondheim, and wrote their first song together. After seven shows you may have seen, two shows you have yet to see and a show that will never see the light of day, they invite you to celebrate their collaboration in an evening of foul-mouthed swans, a town besieged by vampires and songs they didn't write with each other. Dust off your yarmulke (optional) and join the fun!"
Opening number medley:
Joanna Young sings "It's My Job" from Small Town Story:
Ann Harada sings "Aunt Evelyn's Inspirational Advice" from The 7-Year B*tch:
Nick Cearley sings "The Lobster and You" from ...And Then I Wrote A Song About It:
"Dear Jane Curtin" with Sammy Buck and Nick Cearley:
George Salazar sings "I Don't See The Wires" from The Art of Joey Feldman:
Becca Ayers sings "Happy for You" from The 7-Year B*tch:
Nathan Johnson sings "Be With Me" from Like You Like It:
"Promised Land" from Ugly: The Unauthorized But Totally Accurate Sequel to The Ugly Duckling:
Sammy Buck and Dan Acquisto sing "The Reversal Song" from The 7-Year B*tch:
Joanna Young sings "Whenever We Would Dance," written for Dancing in the Dark:
James Donegan and Becca Ayers sing "UGLY" songs:
Hollis Scarborough and Nathan Johnson perform songs loosely inspired by "'Salem's Lot":