Tony Award nominee Robert Cuccioli starred in titular dual roles in the 1997 musical. Here are performances of the show's iconic ballad from Cuccioli, Robert Evan, Anthony Warlow and more. For more on the musical, visit the Playbill Vault.
Cuccioli on "The Rosie O'Donnell Show":
Donnie Osmond and Susan Boyle:
Highlights of the Broadway-bound Jekyll & Hyde tour, starring Maroulis:
Mark Vincent on "America's Got Talent":