Tony Award Winner Betty Buckley Looks Back at Carrie On Stage and Screen

By Adam Hetrick
08 Mar 2012

Betty Buckley
Photo by Peter Cunningham

The cheers! (and the booing...)
BB: During the end, I come down the stairs with a kitchen knife behind my back, and I'm singing to Carrie this lullaby to comfort her after what she's been through. Then I stab her, and then she reaches over, stops my heart, and she climbs down a few more steps and dies. Then there's a last bit of music, a blackout, and the whole house starts booing, which I'd never heard before in the entirety in my career. My mind reeled back to these remembrances of the Survey of Theatre course in my freshman year of college with these stories of Jacobean drama creating riots in the audiences and Ibsen's plays creating riots, and I thought, "Oh my God! It's a bona fide theatrical riot! I've never experienced this. This is very exciting!" [Laughs.] And, Linzi's like three-feet away from the audience, and I was back up the stairs, so I was safe. [Laughs.] She turns around to me in the darkness — this wonderful, little 17-year-old dynamo — turns around to me in the dark, terrified, and says, "What do we do?," because she's trusted me through this whole thing, and I was like, "We have to get up!" I start laughing and we get up, and, as soon as the lights came up, the whole place went into this huge, unanimous standing ovation. In a moment, it went from boos to this massive, full-house standing ovation!

Opening night and the critics.
BB: We got very mixed reviews. People remember it only as being this massive flop, and it truly wasn't. It was provocative and startling and scary, and yes, there were also scenes in the school where the kids were dressed in togas and stuff, and it was just bizarre. There were songs that were just too over-the-top, but it was all those things. It was very dangerous, I think, this show, mainly because of what Linzi and I established as the center of truth in the piece. Some reviewers really gave us raves, and others really trashed us. Frank Rich, at the New York Times, for example, really loved Linzi's and my work. He loved those sequences, but he really wrote the review so that we couldn't lift a quote.

My opening-night remembrance was going to the party, hearing that we'd kind of been savaged and that we had good reviews, too. And, I left and was driving home alone in this limousine, and I pulled over to get a copy of the New York Times. I read the review, laughing, in the back seat because he had worded it so carefully that it was clear that he wanted to kill the show. He wouldn't even let us have that. He wouldn't even let us have quotes for Linzi and myself, and so, I thought, "Man, oh man! You really want it to die."

Betty Buckley and Linzi Hateley
photo by Peter Cunningham

To be honest with you, I think that had they pushed passed those reviews that it could have become event theatre. It was sold out the whole time we ran for those 21 performances. You couldn't get a ticket. I think it would have become something like Rocky Horror Picture Show. That event kind of musical where people come and dress as the characters and recite the lines with the audience. I think it would've become something along those lines.

On Carrie for a 2012 audience.
BB: I'm really glad for the guys — for the creative team — that they got this revival happening, and it's a new take on it. They've got a lot of new material, and I think it's awesome because the music deserves to be heard. It's definitively all-American, and the bullying theme—finally we're conscious of that as a culture.

Dying for De Palma on screen.
BB: The death scenes were a riot. My death scene was this pendulum machine, which was the basketball backboard, and there was a foot of balsa wood where when the pendulum hits the wall, the balsa breaks against the body, so that we're (the stunt woman and I) not actually crushed in half—hopefully. But they never tested out the machines.

I remember right before they shot my sequence, they did this thing with our stunt coordinator, Dick [Ziker], where they threw him backwards across the room in this machine and he's supposed to land on mattresses. They overshot it, and he landed on the floor on his tailbone. He really injured himself, so I thought, "Oh, swell! They really know what they're doing, don't they?" So when it came time for my death scene, they had never run this machine to see if it worked. I was like, "Okay!" We shot four takes, four cameras of the machine coming down to crush me, and it's supposed to stop before it hits me each time. That's real terror on the film. That's not me acting at all because I was pretty sure it wasn't going to work. [Laughs.]

We, as a cast, all came to each other's death scenes because the death scenes went on for over a week in the prom sequence. Each time somebody was going to die, we would all come watch their death scene and go out afterwards and celebrate. It was really fun. It was a group of fun, wonderful young actors making our debut, and we had a good time making the movie.