THE DVD SHELF: "Being John Malkovich," Julie Andrews as "Victor Victoria," and the Vintage "Dearest Enemy"

By Steven Suskin
20 May 2012

Cover art for "Victor Victoria"

If ever there were a heyday of the Hollywood musical sex farce, the time had long passed by 1982. Yet that is precisely what Blake Edwards — of "Breakfast at Tiffany's" and the "Pink Panther" franchise — turned out with Victor Victoria [Warner Archives]. Taking a 1933 German film as source material, Edwards came up with a clever and frothy concoction that worked grandly on several levels. (One suspects that the world-wide success of the 1978 French film "La Cage aux Folles" helped convince M-G-M to go along with the project.)

This is the one about the singer — Julie Andrews, wife to Edwards — who pretends to be a man pretending to be a woman pretending to be a man etc. Everything works exceptionally well (except for some tired "Pink Panther"-like detective humor). Andrews does a fine job; I don't suppose any viewer ever thought for a moment that she was a man, but hey — this is the movies. James Garner is good as the Chicago mobster who falls for the guy pretending to be a girl who really is a girl. Lesley Ann Warren is suitably outrageous as the Chicago dancer Garner dumps for his female impersonator, while Alex Karras — former defensive tackle for the Detroit Lions — is extremely funny as Garner's bodyguard.

The treat of the movie is Robert Preston, as an aging performer who takes in the unemployed soprano Victoria and transforms her into the suavely seductive Victor. When Preston and Andrews get up there and do a musical comedy number together — "You and Me," by Henry Mancini and Leslie Bricusse — you are watching musical comedy perfection. Preston — who died in 1987 — was fatally missed when Edwards turned the film into a sub-par Broadway musical in 1995. The stage Victor/Victoria was a mess in many areas, yes; but it would have turned out way better if only they had an actor like Preston who could effortlessly win over the audience with just a twinkle in the eye.

"Victor Victoria" (the film) has now been rereleased as a DVD-on-demand from Warner Archive. This one is a real treat, thanks to Andrews, Preston and — yes — Blake Edwards. Warner Archive is simultaneously releasing two other minor Edwards titles: "S.O.B.", the 1981 film in which Julie famously bared her breasts (and it's a sad thing when that's the most memorable moment); and "Skin Deep," a John Ritter starrer from 1989 in which the most memorable moment centers on two glow-in-the-dark condoms. "The comedy that glows in the dark" is what they used as a tag line in the ads, which sounds kind of desperate.


Cover art for "Dearest Enemy"

The folks at VAI — Video Artists International — have given us yet another one of producer Max Liebman's abridged television adaptations of Broadway musicals. This time up it's Dearest Enemy, and if your immediate reaction is what's that? you are surely in the majority. This 1925 opus was the first book musical by Richard Rodgers and Lorenz Hart. They had been trying in vain to get the show produced. When their revue The Garrick Gaities — intended as a two-performance benefit — proved a substantial success (with a bonafide songhit "Manhattan"), Dearest Enemy found instant backing. The show was moderately successful, with a for-the-time not insubstantial 286-performance run. But it was merely the beginning for Rodgers & Hart. This was the second of their six consecutive hits within eighteen months, with the final two significantly stronger than the first.

Dearest Enemy quickly disappeared, remaining a mere footnote on the boys' resume. So much so that when Liebman phoned for the rights in 1955, Rodgers presumably said "let 'em, but why on earth would they want to do that?" The answer might be that Liebman was searching for something suitable for the highly talented Anne Jeffreys and her husband, the apparently not-as-talented Robert Sterling; the pair's sitcom "Topper" had just gone off the air. Or perhaps Liebman wanted to follow up his success, earlier that year, with an adaptation of A Connecticut Yankee (which had been the fifth R & H hit in the aforementioned string).

And so we have Dearest Enemy. A curiosity for Rodgers & Hart fans, yes, but not one which stands out as a lost gem. The score is mild, featuring a couple of pleasant tunes, "Here In My Arms" and "Bye and Bye." Both attained a certain amount of popularity at the time, but neither make you perk up your ears like the boys' best pre-1927 songs ("Manhattan," "Mountain Greenery," "The Blue Room," "Sleepyhead," "Where's That Rainbow.") However, we do get practically the entire score; and when was the last time you heard "Sweet Peter" (as in Stuyvesant) or "The Hermits"?

Dearest Enemy is suggested by the true story of one Mary Lindley Murray, a Manhattan widow who on September 15, 1776 entertained the Redcoats long enough to allow General Washington to escape to Harlem. Murray's manor house, on a hill at Park Avenue and 36th Street, is long gone. So is the hill itself, although the neighborhood is still called "Murray Hill."

The original book by Herb Fields seems not to have been so hot, so there were no complaints when Liebman assigned his staff guys to drum up a new and apparently pretty much altered one. The staff guys being William Friedberg and Neil Simon. Yes, Neil Simon, eight years before he became Neil Simon. The seventy-seven minute production is on the primitive side, although the quaintish music is somewhat enlivened by arranger Irv Kostal.

Joining Ms. Jeffreys and her husband is Cyril Ritchard, who had just finished hooking around with Mary Martin in Peter Pan. Ritchard, as General Howe, makes the most out of the material; he is the only performer who looks like he knows what he's doing (and like he is thoroughly enjoying himself). Cornelia Otis Skinner also stars, as Mrs. Murray.

As I was watching the newly rescued DVD of the 1955 Dearest Enemy, I received an email from someone else altogether telling me that plans are underway for a full recording of the 1925 version, with full orchestra. So while we might not have heretofore heard much about Rodgers & Hart's Dearest Enemy, the show might soon become considerably more familiar.

Visit to check out theatre-related DVDs for sale.