Groff, who received a Tony nomination for his performance as radical teenager Melchior Gabor in Spring Awakening, was also seen on Broadway in In My Life. He most recently appeared on the New York stage in The Submission and plays the character of Jesse St. James on "Glee."

Learn more about Groff's theatrical history in the Playbill Vault.

*

Here are the highlights from the 2013 Miscast gala. In hopes to top last year's performance of "Anything Goes," Groff performed "If Mama Was Married" with Christian Borle and "Let Me Be Your Star" with Jeremy Jordan. Read the Playbill.com recap of the evening here.