ON THE RECORD: The Gershwins' 1930 Version of Strike Up the Band and Barbara Carroll's Latest CD

By .(JavaScript must be enabled to view this email address)
28 Jun 2011

We listen to the premiere studio recording of the 1930 Broadway version of the Gershwins' Strike Up the Band, plus the Barbara Carroll Trio's "How Long Has This Been Going On?"


Strike Up the Band: The 1930 Broadway Score [PS Classics PS-1100]
The first reaction of most fans of the great songwriters of the first half of the 20th century to the news that PS Classics has brought us a restored and reconstructed recording of George & Ira Gershwin's 1930 musical Strike Up the Band will be one of joy. Fans with extensive CD collections might, after a moment, scratch their collective heads and say, "but don't we already have this?"

The correct answers are: joy? yes; have this? no.

Strike up the Band marked a turning point in the development of the Gershwins' craft, both George and Ira. George spent the early years (1918-1923) of his brief career developing a style in which he could add those bluesy notes and that "modern" syncopation to the traditional Broadway sound. The year 1924 marked his breakthrough, with both "Rhapsody in Blue" (which made him an overnight celebrity) in February and his first jazz-musical, Lady, Be Good!, in December.

This started a second period (1924-1929) in which Gershwin fired off an astonishing array of wonderful songs. All were show tunes, the Broadway musical being his playground, and many were exceptional; but they were for the most part interchangeable. "Fascinating Rhythm," "Someone to Watch Over Me," "Do-Do-Do," "'S Wonderful" could have been used for any of a number of musicals; "The Man I Love," in fact, was used in three of them without ever finding a suitable slot.

The older Ira, meanwhile, started his career somewhat later and only began to catch up to George in 1926 or so. In 1927, the boys began to develop — with librettist George S. Kaufman — a new kind of satirical musical, sort of an American distillation of Gilbert & Sullivan. Strike Up the Band was the first of these shows, but it failed miserably and closed in Philadelphia. The boys went back to those interchangeable musical comedies, but the germ was set. In late 1929 they turned once more to the intriguing Strike Up the Band, with Kaufman replaced — at his own behest — by his sometime collaborator Morrie Ryskind. The new Strike Up the Band arrived in 1930, beginning Gershwin's final Broadway period (1930-1935). The success of the show — not just commercially, but artistically — led directly to the 1931 Gershwin-Kaufman-Ryskind Pulitzer Prize-winner, Of Thee I Sing. But that is outside the scope of our discussion.

The 1927 Strike Up the Band was an experimental work, with the satirical groundwork evident but somewhat tentatively executed by the songwriters. In the intervening two years, the Gershwins' continued development brought them to a place where they could figure out just how to accomplish it. The 1930 Strike up the Band was a masterpiece, relatively so at least; if the musical never had an afterlife and quickly disappeared from memory, it was perhaps because their next two musicals — Girl Crazy and Of Thee I Sing — were significantly stronger.

Ira's widow Leonore embarked on a series of recorded restorations of Gershwin musicals just before her death in 1991, starting with Girl Crazy and Strike Up the Band. Both versions of the latter show were recorded at the time, with the 1927 recording released by Roxbury Records in 1991. Rather than releasing the 1930 version back then, the Ira and Leonore Gershwin Trusts moved on to a series of other restorations (including Lady, Be Good! and Pardon My English). Tommy Krasker, the Gershwin archivist who did the Strike Up the Band restoration, has remained involved with the Gershwin recording activities through the years; with the blessings and cooperation of the Trust, he has now released the 1930 Strike Up the Band on his PS Classics label.

But don't we already have this? That is, don't those of us with the 1927 Strike Up the Band on our shelf have — for all intents and purposes — Strike Up the Band?

No. Most writers, reworking a show that closed a couple of years earlier, would have simply slipped rewritten material in amongst the old pages and let it go at that. Let the bookwriter make whatever changes he wishes; we'll write new songs as necessary, and salvage the rest. But that's not what happened here. Ira, I suppose, must have said to George: "If we're going to rewrite it, let's rewrite it." Every number that was carried over from the first to the second has changes in both lyric and music, and not just the minor change of cheese to chocolate. (As those of you familiar with the show might recall, the plot concerns a manufacturer who instigates a war with Switzerland over tariffs. In 1927, the product in question is cheese; in 1930, it is chocolate. In either case, the manufacturer is accused of using Grade B milk!)

There are stretches within the numbers that remain the same, of course; and in the modern-day recording studio, they could easily patch in new words here, new notes there, and new instrumental bridges with the push of a button. When they recorded the two scores in 1990, such patchwork was more complicated than it was worth. So they just recorded the material twice. (The two versions of the show used a somewhat different instrumentation; I don't know if they went so far as to religiously alter these in the recording studio, but I wouldn't be surprised if they did.)

Comparing the two versions of the same numbers is interesting, and fun; the musical routines are often slightly altered, probably to accommodate differences in staging. And Ira never seems to have stopped working; quite simply, he seems to have been a more accomplished and playful lyricist in 1930 than he was in 1927. A case in point: in the Gilbert & Sullivan-like introductory number "Typical Self-Made American," the manufacturer originally tells us:

I got a job and worked both day and night at it;
I watched the cheese but never watched the clock.
The big boss thought I was so very bright at it
That when he died he left me all the stock.

In 1930, he doesn't change his tune; but watch what Ira slips into the last line:

I got a job and worked both day and night at it;
And all the day I never watched the clock.
The big boss thought I was so very bright at it
That when I poisoned him he left me all the stock.

The same, but different. Enough said.

Eight new songs were added in 1930, including "I've Got a Crush on You" (which had been written for a 1928 musical) and "Soon"; ten or so were deleted (including, alas, "The Man I Love"). The second act of the new version, in fact, retained only one song from 1927. Part of these changes stemmed from the addition of the star comedians Bobby Clark and Paul McCullough, in roles that didn't exactly exist in 1927. So the 1930 version of Strike Up the Band isn't nearly the same as the 1927 Strike Up the Band. And the recordings are significantly different. The original recording, a two-CD set, contained an appendix of six songs from the 1930 version. These are included on the 2011 release, but as best I can tell these are the only overlapping tracks whatsoever. Five of them, anyway, as the sixth is altered.

All of which is to say: yes — this new Strike Up the Band is a different recording of a different show. And in my opinion, a better recording of a better show. The 1991 release always seemed to dissolve into quaintness for me; in retrospect, this is probably due to those faded boy-girl duets which were subsequently cut. Strike Up the Band, in the 1930 version on this new release, sounds pert and fresh and plays well; which is perhaps why the show was a hit, the second time around. The personnel is the same, with John Mauceri conducting. The entire project needed new orchestrations, as the originals were lost (save two charts); these were reconstructed — and excellently so — by a team headed by Russell Warner, with contributions from the likes of Larry Wilcox, Bill Brohn, and Sid Ramin. (The new disc is dedicated to the memory of Warner, who died on April 26, and who excelled at recreating the original sound of Kern and Gershwin.) What's more, the two recordings are built around the singing talents of Rebecca Luker and Brent Barrett. Who were astoundingly good circa 1990, and who both remain so today. The pair went into the studio this winter to finish some vocals, in fact, and I daresay you can't pick out the sections in which they are 20 years older.


1 | 2 Next