*

BUSKER ALLEY [Jay CDJAY 1400]
There's an old story about a fellow pacing impatiently in the box office lobby at a flop musical. A lady on ticket line, seeing how upset the fellow was, said, "If you're so unhappy, why don't you just try to get your money back?" And the fellow, who it turns out was the producer of said flop musical, said, "Lady, I wish I could!"

There are any number of times during a tryout when the producers or investors would like nothing more than to get their money back, wash their hands, and jump on the milk train back to Grand Central. Rarely do they have the option, needless to say. Once in a very great while there is an escape clause, which leaves you with another conundrum: do you continue to roll the dice, hoping that your Away We Go! will transform itself into Oklahoma!; or do you just take the money and send the actors home?

Oh it's great to have a big deal, ticket-sellin' star, sure, and an expensive proposition too. One of the many related costs is that extra insurance policy you need to take. This helps cover costs when the star is out sick and everybody demands a refund. But you also have the case where the star is unable to return to the show for an extended period, or never. If you are properly covered, you have an abandonment clause that will cover the initial investment. Close the show, get your money back.

If you think the show is so good, even without that star, you plunge on and go ahead. Which is more or less what happened when Bob Fosse suffered a heart attack during the rehearsals of Chicago. They put everything in mothballs until he was sufficiently recovered, and then went ahead. With Miss Moffat, the producers were wise to collect the insurance money and pay back the investors. This didn't help the actors, who were banking on a Broadway credit and enough work weeks to qualify for unemployment insurance, but then — that's show business. So the investors of Miss Moffat came out whole, while the investors of some such concurrent show as Mack & Mabel — which was flawed but easily 30 times better — lost it all.

Which brings us to Busker Alley. Back in 1938, Charles Laughton starred as a busker — one of those street entertainers who used to perform outside West End musicals — in the film "St. Martin's Lane." Charles Laughton = Tommy Tune, you might naturally think. Tommy Tune took Busker Alley on the road for an extended tryout tour, the sort where they expect to coin money by the bucketful before braving the lions of Broadway. The show started in Louisville in April 1995, receiving a mixed reception; in some towns it was hot, and in some towns not. (Along the way, they changed the title to Stage Door Charley and Buskers — as if that was the root of the problem!) They reached Tampa in early October, at which point Mr. Tune broke his ankle. Have him play the show hobbling around in a cast? Replace him with some suitable star replacement? Nathan Lane, maybe? Or just send everyone home and take the insurance money? Bingo!

That was the end of Busker Alley until November 2006, when the York Theatre presented it for a one-night fundraiser directed by Tony Walton (who knew quite a bit about the world of buskers from his London days, and who also designed the Tommy Tune tour). The resulting CD reveals a score that is a whole lot more interesting than one might have expected. Credit, to an enormous extent, rests in the hands of Jim Dale; he simply charms his way through the score (13 songs, he has), and makes you want to see him do it in person. That Dale is good is no surprise; he arrived stateside at the Circle in the Square in 1974 playing a zany version of Moliere's Scapin, under the title Scapino, and I confess that I am still laughing from that performance.

Busker Alley might make a stage vehicle for Dale if only it was stronger, but there's the rub. The songs, by Richard M. and Robert B. Sherman of "Mary Poppins" fame, are rather charming, and offers the listener an entertaining hour's worth. But the Busker score is full of music hall-type turns, and after a while they do seem to be interchangeable. This was a problem, to an even greater extent, with the Sherman's first Broadway musical, Over Here!: it all sounded the same. (Mind you, I was so unenamored, sitting at the Shubert, that I still have never had the desire to break the wrapper on my Over Here! LP.) Busker has a good deal of lilt to it, but after listening three or four times, few of the songs stand out. The musical arrangements, from Aaron Gandy and Mark York, sound especially good considering they are working with only five pieces. But the Sherman brothers give us too much sameness.

The York seems to have gone all out for this reading of the show, which seems to some extent to have been propelled by the energetic Mr. Walton. Lending a hand to the fundraising effort, Glenn Close — whose career was given a boost when she played Dale's wife in Barnum — contributed her participation. She is present on the CD delivering an opening and closing speech (within the context of the show), and sings the closing ballad (a reprise of "He Had a Way"). Jessica Grovι plays the girl — this is the one about the middle-aged veteran who takes the youngster under his wing, only to watch her scale the heights and leave him behind — but without the impact of Dale; in fairness, her material seems considerably weaker. George S. Irving and Anne Rogers serve as a couple of folksy oldtimers, with plenty of relish and a slather of marmite. Mr. Irving is well-known hereabouts; he might even rank number one on our local longest-active list, having first trod the boards on the opening night of Oklahoma! in 1943. Ms. Rogers is a surprise. This is apparently the same Anne Rogers who created the role of Polly in the initial production of The Boy Friend, in 1954, and went on to star as Amalia ten years later in the London production of She Loves Me (which was co-produced by Walton). Stateside, she charmed the customers as Eliza Doolittle, heading the first national tour.

So chalk Busker up as a pleasant and tuneful surprise. Were the 1995 producers wise, once Mr. Tune buskered his ankle, to pull the plug? Probably so. The same producers faced the same situation in 2005, with Christina Applegate and Sweet Charity. That time, after a great deal of turbulence, they decided to go ahead and roll the dice. Providing a great opportunity for Charlotte d'Amboise and numerous workweeks for actors, musicians, stagehands, dressers, ushers and even concessionaires. No payday for the investors, though. Continued...