PLAYBILL PLAYLIST: Billy Porter, Annaleigh Ashford, Will Van Dyke and Friends Pick Songs to Deal With a Break-Up

By Michael Gioia
09 Oct 2013

Tamika Sonja Lawrence: "Can We Pretend" (Bill Withers). My favorite break-up song of all time is "Can We Pretend" by Bill Withers. It's so gut wrenching and personifies the first thought many of us have after heartbreak: "I wish I would have never let you into my heart."