Judy McLane

Judy McLane has spent the last decade playing most every great female role in the musical theatre canon, including several triumphs at New Jersey's Paper Mill Playhouse. Within the past year's time, the talented singer-actress nabbed a Drama Desk nomination for her work as Vienna in Off-Broadway's Johnny Guitar and a Helen Hayes nomination for her role as Phyllis in the Signature Theatre's acclaimed production of Stephen Sondheim's Follies. McLane, who made her Broadway bow in the original cast of Chess (her Broadway credits also include Kiss of the Spider Woman and Aspects of Love), is now back on The Great White Way in another ABBA-scored musical, Mamma Mia!. McLane is part of the long-running musical's new trio of leading ladies, which includes Parade's Carolee Carmello as Donna and Taboo's Liz McCartney as Rosie. And, the show may just be better than ever with this powerhouse trio belting out the string of ABBA hits. I recently had the chance to chat with McLane, who spoke about her return to Broadway as Tanya, her work in regional theatre, her transition from classical singer to Broadway belter and what it meant to be able sing the demanding title role in Evita. That interview follows.

Question: How's your run in Mamma Mia! going so far?
Judy McLane: It's a ball. I'm having such a great time!

Q: How does it feel to be back on Broadway?
Judy: I'm so thankful. It's great. It feels like home to be honest — it really does. It's been awhile, and I've worked tons regionally. This whole year has been just like a snowball. It's been a really wonderful year. It's so great because it feels right.

Q: How did casting coming about for the show?
Judy: Actually, I had gone in a long time ago for it. I've been through phases with [Mamma Mia!]. The very first time, when it was just coming out, I went in for [the role of] Tanya. Then, they started calling me in for Donna a couple times, and then I didn't go in for awhile. This time I went back actually for Donna, and during the course of the audition, they said, "Can you read Tanya?" It was at the callbacks, and I just read for it the one time, and they said, "Okay, that's it."

Q: Did you have a preference for which role?
Judy: You know, it's so funny, you always think, "Well, Donna's the bigger part, and it's great songs," but I love this part. I just love this part! I think there's a part of me that can relate on a lot of sides to Tanya — being in the business, we have certain personas and we're out doing things. I'm very much like Donna in a lot of ways — most of my friends say, "You're earthy and . . . ," but there's a part of me that just loves this dressing up, the nails have to be done and the hair is coifed. And, she's so much fun. I'm allowed to be myself as well, bring a lot of what I have [to the part], especially when the three of us are together. We can go back to those times when you're with people that you just can let go with, which is really fun.

Q: Were you an ABBA fan before this?
Judy: I don't know if I was an ABBA fan, but I grew up with a lot of this stuff. I enjoy their music, [but] I don't have any of their CDs. But, of course, I did Chess — that was my first Broadway show, so it's kind of nice to come around again . . . [Chess has such] a great score. I've done that show about five times, and it's kind of nice to do another one of their shows.

Q: Do you have a favorite moment in the show for your character?
Judy: There's a few of them, but I think the bedroom scene with the three girls is the most fun. It's [also] the most grueling. Last night we looked at each other, and at one point I could see it in Carolee's eyes — by the eighth show of the week, your lungs are burning, and you're thinking, "I cannot do another jump-split. I can't do it!" [Laughs.] But because of the camaraderie between the three of us, I think that's my favorite scene. And, also, I love the part with the boys. The guys that I get to dance with are so much fun. What could be better than these beautiful men dancing around you? [Laughs.] And they're gorgeous guys, and they're all young and have these hot little bodies, so I'm having a ball.

Q: You talked a little about how last year was such a great year for you. Tell me about your experience with Johnny Guitar.
Judy: You know, it was interesting, I had been working so much regionally, a lot of Paper Mill and a lot of great regional theatres all over the country and doing a lot of symphony work. I hadn't been in town in awhile. Most of my friends were more frustrated, I think, than I was. [Laughs.] But coming back and creating a part was just like a little dream. I just had a ball with this part. I didn't try to do Joan Crawford. I took a lot of Susan Hayward or Barbara Stanwyck and I soaked myself in those movies. I think to be rewarded with a Drama Desk nomination and a Drama League honor was just the icing on the cake. It was just a really special year to be acknowledged like that. It was lovely to be back in town after so long.

Q: And you also starred in Follies at the Signature. . .
Judy: That was an unbelievable experience, that little tiny house down there, but the cast was amazing. I was working with Flo Lacey [as Sally Durant] and Joe Dellger [as Ben Stone] and all these great D.C. actors. And, that show I could still be doing — the part is just ridiculous how wonderful it is. There's an essence of a tiny bit of Tanya in it, but Tanya is so much more fun-loving, but there's some tiny little similarity between them. . . I had done this great show and then got rewarded by getting a Helen Hayes nomination. It all came at once, and it was really, really lovely.

Q: What are some of the favorite productions you've done regionally? I remember seeing you as Evita at Paper Mill about ten years ago.
Judy: Paper Mill has been a really wonderful place for me. That's like my family out there. I've had the opportunity to work my chops by doing [Man of] La Mancha and doing Victor/Victoria — those kind of things have really been special. Doing my first production of Chess out there with Robbie Marshall directing — it was pretty amazing. I got to work with great people out at Paper Mill, but around the country I've done some really lovely and wonderful things. One of my favorite things has been Follies — the cast was amazing, and the material is just so rich. You can't beat it. And, I think one of my favorite things I've ever done is another Sondheim show, the national of Into the Woods as the Baker's Wife. I've had the opportunity to do some really great parts . . . It's so funny going to do Evita out at the MUNY, which is a 12,000-seat outdoor theatre. You think you're in Buenos Aires. You look out, you raise your arms, and you think, "This is another country!" [Laughs.] And, yet, because I've worked with so many people that have been on Broadway and are in the Broadway scene, I feel like I never really lost the connection, so that's been nice. But Mamma Mia!, I still can't get over how much of a blast it is to do. The other night I actually started chuckling to myself. When we came out of the trap, rise out of the floor, and the audience is screaming, I thought, "Oh my God, this is like a rock concert!" [Laughs.] Continued...