The 10 PM concert featured musical direction by Kurt Crowley on "a variety of styles including pop/rock, soul, contemporary musical theatre and new works." Videography is by Shoshana Feinstein.
Joining Gotay were Adam Chanler-Berat ( Peter and the Starcatcher, Next to Normal), Sara Kapner ( Bare), Zak Resnick ( Mamma Mia!), Julia Mattison ( Godspell), Hunter Ryan Herdlicka ( A Little Night Music), Sharone Halevy (NYMF'S The Hatpin), George Salazar ( Godspell) Carlton Terrence Taylor Jr., Alex Kirshner and Josephine Spada.
Gotay has also been seen in Rent at the Pioneer Theater Company and Westchester Broadway Theater.
Gotay and Chanler-Berat sing a mashup of Carly Rae Jepsen's "Call Me Maybe" and "I'll Cover You" from Rent:
Gotay sings "Some Kind of Wonderful" by Grand Funk Railroad:
Gotay, Kirshner, Spada and Taylor Jr. sing "End of Time":
Gotay sings "Balloon" by Blake Pfeil:
Gotay, Kirshner, Spada and Taylor Jr. sing "That Smile":
Gotay and Resnick sing "Ready To Be Loved" by Benj Pasek and Justin Paul:
Gotay sings "Make You Feel My Love" and "Gavin's Song":
Gotay and Kapner sing "Joey Is A Punk Rocker" by Joe Iconis:
Gotay sings "Manhattan Speaks" by Blake Pfeil:
Gotay, Halevy and Herdlicka sing a "Sondheim Medley":
Kirshner, Spada and Taylor Jr. sing "Billionaire" and "Price Tag":
Gotay and Mattison sing "Basket Case" by Sara Bareilles, with accompaniment by Salazar and Mattison:
Gotay sings "Perfect Moment" from Bring it On: