The new musical opened March 1, 1979, starring Angela Lansbury and Len Cariou, who would both go on to win Tony Awards for their performances. Supporting cast members included Victor Garber as Anthony, Sarah Rice as Johanna and Ken Jennings as Tobias.
In his New York Times review, Richard Eder offered a qualified rave, celebrating "a powerful, coruscating" book and score tempered by a 'confusion of purpose.'"
"These are defects; vital ones," he concluded, "but they are the failures of an extraordinary, fascinating, and often ravishingly lovely effort."
The production dominated the 1979 Tony Awards with eight wins, including honors for Stephen Sondheim's score, Hugh Wheeler's book, and Harold Prince's direction.