Andrew Samonsky Joins Cast of Broadway's Scandalous; Ensemble Announced

News   Andrew Samonsky Joins Cast of Broadway's Scandalous; Ensemble Announced
Andrew Samonsky, a late-run Lt. Cable in Lincoln Center Theater's South Pacific, has joined the cast of the new Broadway musical Scandalous: The Life and Trials of Aimee Semple McPherson. All but one principal — the choice role of Aimee's mother — have been announced. Tickets go on sale by phone and online Aug. 20.

Andrew Samonsky
Andrew Samonsky

In the tale of the real-life evangelic superstar, Samonsky will play the dual roles of Harold McPherson (Aimee's second husband) and Kenneth Ormiston (the sound engineer hired by Aimee to produce her radio show during the height of her nationwide fame).

The producers announced Samonsky and the ensemble members on Aug. 17. Preview performances begin Oct. 13 at the Neil Simon Theatre. Opening night is Nov. 15.

Scandalous has book and lyrics by Kathie Lee Gifford and music by David Pomeranz and David Friedman.

Samonsky received a Drama Desk Award nomination for the role of Frank Russell in Michael John LaChiusa's Queen of the Mist Off-Broadway. He originated roles in James Lapine and William Finn's Little Miss Sunshine at La Jolla Playhouse and Tales of the City at American Conservatory Theater in San Francisco.

As previously reported, Scandalous stars two-time Tony Award nominee Carolee Carmello (Sister Act, Mamma Mia!, Parade) as Aimee Semple McPherson; two-time Tony Award winner George Hearn (Sunset Blvd., La Cage aux Folles, Sweeney Todd) as James Kennedy and Brother Bob; Edward Watts (Finian's Rainbow) as Robert Semple and David Hutton; and Roz Ryan (Chicago, Dreamgirls) as Emma Jo Schaeffer. The role of Minnie, Aimee's mother, has not been cast. The ensemble of Scandalous includes Nick Cartell, Hannah Chin, Joseph Dellger, Erica Dorfler, Carlos L. Encinias, Corey Greenan, Benjamin J. Howes, Karen Hyland, Alison Luff, Jesse Nager, Sam Strasfeld, Betsy Struxness, Elizabeth Ward Land, Billie Wildrick, Dan'yelle Williamson and Matt Wolfe.

David Armstrong, artistic director of Seattle's 5th Avenue Theatre, where the work was seen in 2011 under the title of Saving Aimee, again directs the show, making his Broadway debut.

Music direction and vocal arrangements are by Joel Fram, choreography is by Lorin Latarro. Gifford also has an "additional music by" credit, for one bawdy song that she authored.

The creative team of Scandalous also includes scenic designer Walt Spangler (Desire Under the Elms), costume designer Gregory A. Poplyk (making his Broadway debut), Tony-winning lighting designer Natasha Katz (Once, Aida), sound designer Ken Travis (Newsies, Memphis) and Tony-winning orchestrator Bruce Coughlin (The Light in the Piazza).

Carolee Carmello in a pre-Broadway production of Scandalous: The Life and Trials of Aimee Semple McPherson.
photo by Chris Bennion

Scandalous: The Life and Trials of Aimee Semple McPherson is produced by Dick and Betsy DeVos, Foursquare Foundation (connected to the church McPherson founded) and in association with The 5th Avenue Theatre (David Armstrong, Executive Producer and Artistic Director; Bernadine Griffin, Managing Director; Bill Berry, Producing Director) and Jeffrey Finn, Executive Producer.

Tickets are $57-$127 for all performances (all prices include a $2 facility fee) and will be available beginning Aug. 20 by contacting and at (877) 250-BWAY (2929).

Tickets may also be purchased in-person at the Neil Simon Theatre Box Office beginning Sept. 17.

For more information, visit


Carmello reprises the charismatic role that she played last fall in a Seattle tryout. The 20th-century evangelical superstar Aimee Semple McPherson was the American religious leader who staged provocative illustrated sermons, fed the hungry and famously vanished.

Carmello is the versatile powerhouse actress-singer who was Tony Award-nominated for her work in Lestat and Parade. She plays the controversial character from her teenage years to maturity. Gifford told that she originally wrote the show for two actresses, but when Carmello was cast, she told Gifford she was up for the challenge of playing the wide range of McPherson's life. This will be Carmello's 12th Broadway show, following such titles as Sister Act, The Addams Family, Mamma Mia!, Urinetown and more.

Gifford — a singer, Broadway actress, "Today" talk-show host and humanitarian — lamented that McPherson has "fallen through the cracks of history," even though her evangelical efforts continue today. Foursquare Foundation, one of the producers of Scandalous, is affiliated with The Foursquare Church, which McPherson founded. Today, The Foursquare Church has more than 1,800 U.S. churches and almost 60,000 churches and meeting places in 140 countries. Read more about the history of the International Church of the Foursquare Gospel (the organization's official name) here

Kathie Lee Gifford
Photo by Krissie Fullerton

Gifford called McPherson (1890-1944) a major celebrity and social force — as popular then as today's "Madonna, Lady Gaga and Oprah, if you put them all together."

The property's earlier titles Hurricane Aimee and Saving Aimee didn't quite hit the nail on the head, Gifford said, and the creators didn't want a marquee that suggested sermons or church. "I don't want anybody thinking that they're coming to church," Gifford said. "She was a Pentecostal evangelist — and that is about as theatrical as you get. I don't want to scare off anybody. I've been obsessed by her since I first heard her name more than 40 years ago in college."

Of the title change, she told, "We've been looking for the right title as long as I've been looking for the right story."

There have been trims and rewrites since Seattle, Gifford said. "We have so much story to tell, some of the best songs had to go…if they didn't move our story forward then they had to be sacrificed on the altar."

Gifford revealed two other pieces of casting: Ed Watts will play Aimee's first and third husbands, and Roz Ryan will play Emma Jo, a New Orleans brothel keeper. (Beyond Carmello, no other casting has been officially announced.)

Who is the audience for Scandalous? Gifford, herself known as a woman of faith, said she wants "a secular audience...people of faith…people interested in history and feminism…"

While explaining that the creative goal is "to be faithful to her legacy….to what her life story teaches us," Gifford quickly added that Aimee was a force of nature, a tabloid queen, a woman who knew great love (her first husband, missionary Robert Semple) and a figure of mystery (she disappeared for a month, claiming she was a victim of a kidnapping, which could not be proved). In short, Gifford said, both a woman of God and "a helluva woman."

Here's how the producers characterize it in the production announcement: "Set in 1920s Los Angeles, holiness collides with Hollywood in this extraordinary tale of one remarkable woman's charismatic rise to fame amidst scandalous love affairs and growing controversy, inevitably ending in her much-publicized fall from grace."

Today’s Most Popular News: