The two critics' selections were chosen from Broadway, Off-Broadway and Off-Off-Broadway productions. Liza's at the Palace...! placed on both Brantley and Isherwood's lists.
Here are the best of 2008 published (alphabetically) in The New York Times:
Ben Brantley:
Billy Elliot
Blasted
Boeing-Boeing
Dividing the Estate
Gypsy
Hair
Liza's at the Palace...!
The Seagull
South Pacific
Sunday in the Park with George
Brantley also bestowed an unofficial "special lifetime achievement award for sustained sharpness in blunt times" to Forbidden Broadway.
Charles Isherwood:
Adding Machine
Chekhov Lizardbrain
Eccentricities of a Nightingale
Garden of Earthly Delights
Liza's at the Palace...!
On the Town
Our Town
Passing Strange
Streamers
What's that Smell: The Music of Jacob Sterling
For more from The New York Times, visit nytimes.com.