Nunziata Brothers Offer From Pelham to Park Avenue Starting April 20; Jay-Alexander Directs | Playbill

News Nunziata Brothers Offer From Pelham to Park Avenue Starting April 20; Jay-Alexander Directs
Identical twin brothers Will and Anthony Nunziata return to Feinstein's at Loews Regency with a new show, From Pelham to Park Avenue, April 20-24.
Richard Jay-Alexander (center) with Will and Anthony Nunziata
Richard Jay-Alexander (center) with Will and Anthony Nunziata

Richard Jay-Alexander, who has helmed the concert tours of Barbra Streisand, Bette Midler and Bernadette Peters, directs the evenings with musical direction by Ben Toth. Toth is featured at the piano with Jered Egan on bass.

Cabaretgoers can expect to hear the Nunziata brothers' renditions of "Pretty Women," "Make Someone Happy," "I Believe in You," "Swing Is Back in Style" and "Funniculi, Funnicula," among others.

"Working with Will and Anthony Nunziata has been an extraordinary experience," director Jay-Alexander recently told, "for so many reasons. I usually work with more 'seasoned' performers or stars, but when I first saw them I couldn't believe how talented they were — and, yet, I don't think they knew. They are naturals, and that's a particular gift one must be cautious with. Not all people need training. Some just need guidance and coaching. . . . They are young, attractive, smart, grounded, charming, funny — I really believe they can go the distance."

The director said rehearsals were filled "with plenty of laughs, but lots of hard work. Needless to say, I push them because they can take it and do it, and the results are usually immediate. . . . They take their careers seriously and are in no rush. This is a good thing. They are more interested in having careers than in being stars. It's refreshing."

Jay-Alexander added, "It's their story of how they happen to fall in love with the performing arts that is the crux of this show: From Pelham to Park Avenue. You won't believe it. I've heard a lot in my day, but this is one 'for the books.' It's their debut engagement, and we're gonna have some extra fun at the late shows." Will and Anthony Nunziata have traveled the country with their duo concert act, recently as soloists with the Boston Pops, as well as guest artist appearances with the Cleveland Pops Orchestra, Colorado Symphony Orchestra, Cape Cod Symphony Orchestra, and at Jazz at Lincoln Center’s Rose Hall.

The 26-year-old brothers were also part of Sondheim: The Birthday Concert! and Broadway Backwards 5.

Richard Jay-Alexander was formerly a Broadway actor, singer and dancer, who has since directed the critically acclaimed concerts of Barbra Streisand, Bette Midler, Bernadette Peters and Cleere Haran. He was the executive director of Cameron Mackintosh's American company for a decade and was the associate director and executive producer of the original Broadway, touring and Canadian companies of Les Misérables. His recent directorial credits include the acclaimed, sold-out concert versions of Guys and Dolls and Les Miz at the Hollywood Bowl.

Show times are Tuesday-Thursday at 8:30 PM and Friday and Saturday at 8 PM and 10:30 PM. The 8 PM and 8:30 PM shows have a $40 cover with $60 premium seats and an additional $40 food and beverage minimum; the 10:30 PM shows have $25 cover with $40 premium seats and a $25 food and beverage minimum. For all shows, there are a select amount of seats based on availability with a $40 cover charge and no food/beverage minimum.

Feinstein's is located at 540 Park Avenue at 61st Street in New York City. For ticket reservations and club information, call (212) 339-4095 or visit and

Will and Anthony Nunziata
Will and Anthony Nunziata Photo by Walter McBride

Click Here to Shop for Theatre
Merchandise in the Playbill Store
Today’s Most Popular News:

Blocking belongs
on the stage,
not on websites.

Our website is made possible by
displaying online advertisements to our visitors.

Please consider supporting us by
whitelisting with your ad blocker.
Thank you!