Returning to Broadway this fall in the holiday hit Elf, Beth Leavel joins Seth in studio for some reminiscing — they met each other some 23 years ago working in Grease. After Seth explains his unusual athletic wear (turns out it's not a football jersey!), the two get down to business. Leavel reveals her fear of Cats, or at least her fear of auditioning for the Broadway show among a crop of elite dancers. However, she was inspired to overcome her fear (and her not-so-talented feet) and made a splash at her next audition for 42nd Street, featuring a tap number that she demonstrates for Seth.