| Show | CUMULATIVE GROSS |
| A CHORUS LINE | $11,487,821.72 |
| AVENUE Q | $76,151,634.15 |
| AWAKE AND SING!* | $3,384,141.02 |
| BEAUTY AND THE BEAST | $404,772,184.82 |
| BRIDGE AND TUNNEL* | $6,135,551.30 |
| BUTLEY | $4,415,545.21 |
| CHICAGO | $287,078,112.73 |
| COMPANY | $3,604,214.02 |
| DIRTY ROTTEN SCOUNDRELS* | $57,207,558.51 |
| DOUBT* | $27,656,473.00 |
| DR. SEUSS' HOW THE GRINCH STOLE CHRISTMAS! | $10,916,331.17 |
| FAITH HEALER* | $7,583,448.83 |
| GREY GARDENS | $5,097,191.00 |
| HAIRSPRAY | $184,645,053.39 |
| HEARTBREAK HOUSE* | $3,177,762.91 |
| HIGH FIDELITY* | $1,096,115.46 |
| HOT FEET* | $4,835,456.84 |
| JAY JOHNSON: THE TWO AND ONLY* | $587,011.24 |
| JERSEY BOYS | $62,086,794.72 |
| KIKI & HERB: ALIVE ON BROADWAY* | $619,679.50 |
| LES MISÉRABLES | $6,147,247.78 |
| LOSING LOUIE* | $1,548,011.00 |
| MAMMA MIA! | $258,064,041.31 |
| MARTIN SHORT: FAME BECOMES ME | $9,324,578.01 |
| MARY POPPINS | $10,400,226.96 |
| RENT | $238,490,346.25 |
| SHINING CITY* | $3,217,082.00 |
| SPAMALOT | $94,736,296.03 |
| SPRING AWAKENING | $1,398,633.00 |
| SWEENEY TODD* | $22,218,240.00 |
| TARZAN | $26,178,903.34 |
| THE 25TH ANNUAL PUTNAM COUNTY SPELLING BEE | $31,950,003.03 |
| THE APPLE TREE | $1,137,696.96 |
| THE COAST OF UTOPIA | $2,620,933.00 |
| THE COLOR PURPLE | $57,590,252.57 |
| THE DROWSY CHAPERONE | $32,331,662.85 |
| THE HISTORY BOYS* | $16,775,000.40 |
| THE LIEUTENANT OF INISHMORE* | $3,808,105.49 |
| THE LIGHT IN THE PIAZZA* | $28,777,131.00 |
| THE LION KING | $488,149,759.82 |
| THE LITTLE DOG LAUGHED | $1,632,617.66 |
| THE ODD COUPLE* | $28,938,436.00 |
| THE PAJAMA GAME* | $8,885,203.99 |
| THE PHANTOM OF THE OPERA | $634,784,448.97 |
| THE PRODUCERS | $278,984,691.00 |
| THE THREEPENNY OPERA* | $5,806,156.00 |
| THE TIMES THEY ARE A-CHANGIN'* | $2,636,161.00 |
| THE VERTICAL HOUR | $3,502,834.96 |
| THE WEDDING SINGER | $19,106,148.00 |
| THREE DAYS OF RAIN* | $11,427,896.16 |
| WICKED | $209,283,300.00 |
