Day 18: Negotiations Break Down Between League and Union; Talks Will Resume After "Rain Delay" | Playbill

News Day 18: Negotiations Break Down Between League and Union; Talks Will Resume After "Rain Delay"
Negotiations between the League of American Theatres and Producers and Local One, the stagehands union, broke down prior to 8 AM Nov. 27, the 18th day of the strike. Talks, however, will resume Nov. 28.
A union member hands out flyers.
A union member hands out flyers. Photo by Matthew Blank

As he was leaving the talks, James J. Claffey Jr., the president of the union, said, "We don't have a deal. We made some progress, but we'll try again." Union spokesperson Bruce Cohen added, "We got to a point in the negotiations where the two sides couldn't come to an agreement. At this point there is no deal...There will be a deal in the future, hopefully sooner than later."

The League released a statement at 9 AM, which read, "The League of American Theatres and Producers and Local One talked through the night and were unable to reach an agreement. No further talks are scheduled. Performances will be canceled through Wednesday's matinees." An updated League release at 10:15 AM said talks will resume Nov. 28 at 10 AM.

In the early afternoon the union addressed the day-long break between the end of negotiations Nov. 27 and the forthcoming Nov. 28 discussions: "The most recent talks," stated Bruce Cohen, "which began Monday at 6:30 PM and ended without deal Tuesday morning at 7:30 AM in what can be described as a 'rain delay,' will take place on the 19th day of the strike."

Earlier in the morning of Nov. 27, it seemed progress had been made in the ongoing labor dispute between the League and the Union. In fact, union spokesperson Cohen told NY1 at 5 AM Nov. 27, "Right now I'd have to say that it's the ninth inning of the seventh game of the World Series. I'm optimistic because both sides are still talking. Even as the sun rises over Manhattan, people are getting their second wind. There's still hope that before people leave the building today, we'll have an agreement."

When asked at that time how much longer he thought the negotiations would continue, Cohen answered, "I can't tell when it'll be over. Just like baseball, there are no stop watches. At this point people are doing the best they can to see if they can bring the festivities to a conclusion this morning." Negotiations began anew Nov. 25 in Manhattan at the Proskauer Rose law firm. After a marathon day of negotiations — which began the morning of Nov. 25 and continued through 6:30 AM Nov. 26 — talks between the League and the stagehands union were adjourned for 12 hours. At that time, the union released a statement saying, "Neither Local One nor the League will have further comment."

The two sides resumed negotiating 6:30 PM Nov. 26.

The New York Times reports that the League and the union had been able to come to an agreement concerning the load-in, the period when sets are moved into theatres. The two sides have yet to agree on the rules pertaining to rehearsals and other work calls for shows that are currently playing. Wage increases have yet to be addressed, according to the Times.

The vast majority of Broadway shows have been closed since the strike began, and several shows have been forced to postpone their official opening nights. Those shows that remain open include Cymbeline, Mary Poppins, Pygmalion, The Ritz, The 25th Annual Putnam County Spelling Bee, Xanadu and Young Frankenstein. Mauritius, which had been open since the strike commenced, played its final scheduled performance Nov. 25.

Dr. Seuss' How the Grinch Stole Christmas reopened Nov. 25 and will now play its entire run (through Jan. 6, 2008) at the St. James Theatre uninterrupted.

The stagehands strike began Nov. 10 and is currently in its 18th day. The ongoing dispute has also severely affected businesses in the theatre-district area. The City of New York estimates its loss at $2 million per each day of the strike.

Broadway was last darkened by the 2003 musicians' strike, which lasted from Friday, March 7, 2003 to early Tuesday morning, March 11, 2003. That dispute temporarily closed 18 Broadway musicals.

For information regarding refunds of tickets, click here. will provide further information as it is made available.


There was optimism heading into the Nov. 25 meeting. Herschel Waxman, Senior Vice President of the Nederlander Organization who is in charge of Labor Relations, told NY1 Sunday morning, "I think that we're going to be able to make a deal. I'm very optimistic. I think both sides are going to be smart and make a deal."


Prior to Nov. 25, the League and the union were last at the negotiating table Nov. 17 and 18. Many had hoped that that weekend of negotiations — the first time the union and the League had sat down together since Nov. 9 — would lead to a quick resolution. Those in the industry believed that the talks, which began Saturday morning, Nov. 17, would be aided by the participation of Robert W. Johnson, a Disney labor relations executive who flew in to mediate. Thomas C. Short, the president of I.A.T.S.E. who had granted strike authorization to the Broadway stagehands union on Nov. 9, was also part of the weekend meetings. The two days' worth of negotiating at the Westin Hotel proved unfruitful. The producers left the meeting after no agreement could be reached. Following the Sunday talks, producers announced they would cancel shows through the Thanksgiving weekend.

* offers a time line tracking the progress and key points of the ongoing labor dispute between Local One, the stagehands union, and the League of American Theatres and Producers that has darkened most of Broadway.

On July 31, Local One contracts, issued in 2004, expired with the Shubert Organization, Jujamcyn Theaters and the Nederlander Organizations. Local One members continued to report to work without a contract with the League.

Only the Shubert and Jujamcyn camps were permitted to negotiate with Local One. The Nederlander organization, whose contract with Local One also expired, was denied by Local One the permission to bargain collectively with the League in the negotiations. The Nederlander Organization was permitted to sit at the table as a silent observer. The Nederlanders and the union did reach an agreement that said their contract would more or less refelect the same terms agreed upon by Local One and the League.

July 13
Local One and the League of American Theatres and Producers meet for the first time to negotiate a new contract in anticipation of the July 31 expiration date.

July 30
Talks resume between both parties.

July 31
The Local One contract with the League of American Theatres and Producers officially expires. Talks continue.

August 2
The League and Local One meet to hammer out the details of a new work agreement. This will be the only meeting between the two parties to take place in August.

September 6-28
Talks between Local One and the League officially reconvene.

Sept. 30
After a month of talks, the League of American Theatres and Producers sets a deadline for its final offer to Local One. In the event talks should collapse, Broadway begins bracing for a possible Oct. 1 lockout of the stagehands union by the League.

Oct. 1
The League states Broadway will not be affected by a lockout of the stagehands union by theatre owners and producers. Further talks are requested with Local One for Oct. 2 and Oct. 4.

Oct. 4
Unable to reach an agreement, talks between Local One and the League of American Theatres and Producers continue into Oct. 5. Negotiations are scheduled to reconvene following the holiday weekend on Oct. 9.

Oct. 9
At 7 PM the League of American Theatres and Producers makes its final offer to Local One, offering what it describes as "a 16% wage increase over five years; a separate one-time 10% wage increase for the period when shows are loaded in, above and beyond the yearly wage increase; an additional increase for the lowest paid stagehands; a new sick pay provision; and more than a dozen other contract improvements sought by the Union," in exchange for flexibility and streamlining of Local One duties, according to League executive director Charlotte St. Martin.

At 10:10 PM, Local One returned with a "best final offer" of its own. "The union addressed nearly every item on the producers' list and offered imaginative solutions that met the producers' requests. What the producers failed to do was recognize our suggestions with exchanges of its own… Local One is open to exchanges on work rules and other areas, but would not make a concessionary agreement of any kind," Local One president James Claffey Jr. stated in response to the League's "best final offer."

Oct. 10
Negotiations collapse after both sides reject the proposed final offers. St. Martin stated, "In response to our final offer, the Union gave us what they called its final offer, which made no progress on any of the issues we have identified as crucial to these negotiations. In fact, the Union's offer has made the situation worse for all productions, particularly dramatic productions."

The two parties left the table with no further talks scheduled.

Oct. 12
Following an informal meeting of both sides on Oct. 11, the League issued word that there will be no lockout and that shows would go on for the weekend of Oct. 12-14.

Local One president James Claffey Jr. issues word that Local One will convene on Oct. 21 to vote for strike authorization from union members, kicking off a ten-day authorization notice to allow union members to weigh the implications of their actions.

Oct. 16
With talks at a standstill, the League of American Theatres and Producers announced that it will begin implementing the provisions of its final offer. An implementation date of Oct. 23 is set for theatres within the League.

Oct. 17
Local One declines New York City Mayor Michael Bloomberg's offer to mediate negotiations between the League and the Union. Bloomberg was key in ending the 2003 Broadway musician's strike.

Oct. 18
The Nederlander Organization, which has been a silent observer at the table with the Shubert and Jujamcyn camps, announces that it will not implement the terms of the League's proposed contract within its theatres.

Oct. 19
Herschel Waxman, Vice President of Labor Relations of the Nederlander Organization, sends word to Local One president James Claffey, Jr. urging him to accept the League's final offer, stating that should Local One go on strike, it would be in the best interest of the Nederlander Organization to lockout Local One members in solidarity with the League bargaining unit.

Oct. 21
Local One president Claffey declares, "No work in December without a deal." Local One members vote unanimously in favor of strike action against League productions. Union members also vote in favor of allocating $1 million from the union's general fund to help other unions who may be financially affected by the strike. A strike date is not set, but Local One states it will issue notice: "The union will not blind side Broadway theater-goers."

Oct. 23
The League begins implementing terms of its final, rejected offer. The League issues an 11-page summary of its final offer, including withdrawn provisions, and a list of provisions scheduled to take effect. Areas affected include overtime hiring requirements, setting of a production's run crew, meal breaks, premium pay for 7th day or 9th performances, canceled performances, as well as rehearsal, performance, continuity and work calls.

Oct. 24
James Claffey Jr. issues a statement to members of Broadway's stagehands union commending them for working temporarily under the new rules from the League of American Theatres and Producers. He encourages his members to continue their work in order to "convince our co-workers and the public that this Union did all we could for a reasonable period of time before we were pushed and shoved into defending our families and ourselves."

Oct. 29
League issues word that they will reconvene with Local One on Nov. 7, 8 and 9. I.A.T.S.E. president Thomas C. Short will be in attendance. His presence is a necessary component of the Local One constitution requiring an I.A.T.S.E. official to be present for at least one round of negotiations prior to authorizing strike action.

Nov. 7-8
Claffey reports to union members that little-to-no progress has been made during the ongoing negotiations with the League of American Theatres and Producers. At 7:30 PM on Nov. 8, following the latest offer from the League, I.A.T.S.E. president Thomas C. Short grants strike authorization to members of Local One.

Nov. 10
For the first time in the history of the 121-year-old union, Local One issues official word that Broadway stagehands will go on strike at 10 AM "against all theatres governed under the expired collective bargaining agreements of the Shubert, Jujamcyn and Nederlander organizations" – darkening 27 of the 35 productions on Broadway. The first show affected by the strike is the 11 AM performance of Dr. Seuss' How the Grinch Stole Christmas – catching theatregoers and the League off guard.

Other Broadway union members, including actors, musicians, box-office representatives, ushers, wardrobe, hair and make-up personnel honor Local One picket lines. Most Broadway unions release public statements of solidarity with Local One members.

The League of American Theatres and Producers holds a press conference responding to the Broadway stagehands strike. Shubert president Phil Smith, producing director for Jujamcyn Theaters Paul Libin as well as producer and general manager Richard Frankel are among those who joined Charlotte St. Martin for the news conference.

When asked how long she believed the strike will last, St. Martin answered, "As we've never had a strike with Local One, we don't know the answer to that. I have to believe that there will be pressure from the men to come back to work. We are ready to negotiate. We're sending that message as loud and clear as we can send it."

Nov. 11
Local One holds a press conference with Local One president James Claffey Jr.; Bill Dennison, the recording vice-president of Local 802 (the musicians union); and the executive director of Actors' Equity, John Connelly.

Local One, which remained mostly silent during negotiations, offered insight into the bargaining procedures. Claffey said that the union has agreed to some concessions. "We have made compromises. It's just never enough. We've granted 9 or 10 things. They want 30 or 40. They cannot go through our contract after 121 years in one negotiation and just annihilate us."

AEA and Local 802 said it would stand firm with Local One members. Dennison stated, "Unions on Broadway, all of us, are going to stand side by side with the stagehands until this is solved in a way that the members of that proud union are satisfied with, and we will continue to be there with them."

Nov. 12
New York City mayor Michael Bloomberg's offer to provide a neutral space for negotiations is again respectfully declined by Local One.

Nov. 14
The League cancels performances for the Wednesday matinee and evening Broadway performances due to the strike. Aaron Sorkin's The Farnsworth Invention postpones its opening night.

The League issues word that talks will renew with Local One Nov. 17, stating that neither party will issue a public statement until that time.

Nov. 15
The Seafarer, Conor McPherson's latest play scheduled to open Nov. 15 at the Booth Theatre, postpones its opening night after League cancels performances through Nov. 18 due to the strike.

Other productions begin to feel the pinch – both Jersey Boys and Wicked, which usually lead in Broadway grosses, were down nearly half-a-million dollars apiece without their lucrative weekend performances. The picture was grimmer for shows already struggling before the work stoppage.

Nov. 17
The League and Local One return to the bargaining table Saturday morning, Nov. 17 at 10 AM at the Westin Hotel. On hand is Robert W. Johnson, a Disney labor relations executive, hoping to expedite talks between the two parties, as well as I.A.T.S.E. president Tom Short.

Nov. 18
After two days of negotiations at the Westin Hotel, talks between Local One and the League of American Theatres and Producers again end without a new contract for Broadway stagehands.

"Just before the talks broke off, the producers informed Local One that what Local One had offered was simply not enough. The producers then walked out," according to Claffey.

The League commented, "We are profoundly disappointed to have to tell you that talks broke off tonight, and that no further negotiations are scheduled." The League subsequently canceled performances through Nov. 25 for all Broadway productions affected by the strike.

Nov. 19
Local One orders picket lines to come down in front of the St. James Theatre, home of Dr. Seuss' How the Grinch Stole Christmas. This production negotiated its own contract with Local One in August, separate from the League. Grinch general manager Waggett informed, "Our point of view is that our contract is, in fact, still in effect." Claffey thought so, too, informing Grinch producers that the union would allow performances to resume contingent upon approval from Jujamcyn, owner of the St. James Theatre.

At 3 PM Jujamcyn released word that Local One members would not be permitted to return to work at the Grinch until the 26 other theatres darkened by the strike also resumed business.

Nov. 20
The highly anticipated Steppenwolf transfer of August: Osage County misses its opening night due to the Broadway work stoppage, but announces it will extend its engagement through March 9, 2008. The Little Mermaid also announces that it has postponed its opening, originally scheduled for Dec. 6 at the Lunt-Fontanne Theatre, until further notice.

Producers of Dr. Seuss' How the Grinch Stole Christmas go to court seeking an injunction requiring Jujamcyn to reopen the St. James theatre for performances.

Local One requests further talks with the League for the coming weekend. "Local One has only asked the League to meet on Sunday, but we've heard no reply," Claffey has commented.

Alan Cohen, spokesperson for the League, responded that discussions were underway to resume talks, but dates had not been confirmed.

The Nederlander Organization, which owns nine of the 27 Broadway theatres that are currently dark, file a $35 million lawsuit against the union. Producers of the seven shows in those darkened theatres have also joined in the suit, which claims the union has been striking the Nederlander houses only to pressure the League of American Theatres and Producers to make a settlement with the union, which makes the strike "an unlawful secondary boycott."

Nov. 21
The producers of Dr. Seuss' How the Grinch Stole Christmas presented their case against Jujamcyn Theaters in front of State Supreme Court Judge Helen E. Freedman. The producers had filed an injunction Nov. 20 to force Jujamcyn Theaters, who own the St. James, to allow the musical to resume performances.

Judge Freedman grants the injunction filed by The Grinch producers. The musical is scheduled to reopen Friday, Nov. 23 at 11 AM.

Nov. 23
Dr. Seuss' How the Grinch Stole Christmas reopens at the St. James Theatre, bumping the number of Broadway shows playing to nine.

Nov. 25
Talks resume between the League and the union. Mauritius, Manhattan Theatre Club's production at the Biltmore, concludes its limited run as scheduled, leaving eight theatres still operating.

Nov. 26
At 6:30 AM, after a 20-hour negotiating period, talks are adjourned for 12 hours. Talks resumed at 7 PM.

The strike notices at the Brooks Atkinson Theatre, home to <i>Grease</i>.
The strike notices at the Brooks Atkinson Theatre, home to Grease. Photo by Matthew Blank

Click Here to Shop for Theatre
Merchandise in the Playbill Store
Today’s Most Popular News:

Blocking belongs
on the stage,
not on websites.

Our website is made possible by
displaying online advertisements to our visitors.

Please consider supporting us by
whitelisting with your ad blocker.
Thank you!