What Was the Worst Review Nathan Lane Ever Received? | Playbill

Video What Was the Worst Review Nathan Lane Ever Received?
The Broadway vet shares what you need to know about his new play Gary: A Sequel to Titus Andronicus and shares a scathing review of his performance in Present Laughter.

On April 1, The Late Show With Stephen Colbert welcomed one of Broadway’s most beloved performers, Nathan Lane.

Lane returns to Broadway this season—after winning a Tony last year for Angels in America—with Gary: A Sequel to Titus Andronicus. Written by MacArthur Genius recipient Taylor Mac, who uses the preferred pronoun Judy, Gary is currently in previews at the Booth Theatre—starring Lane, Kristine Nielsen, and Julie White—and picks up where The Bard’s Titus Andronicus left off.

READ: Why Nathan Lane Follows Up Angels in America With Taylor Mac’s Gary

“It was Shakespeare's first tragedy and it's famous for being over-the-top, bloody, gory, violent, and in fact seemingly a parody of the Jacobian revenge tragedies,” Lane explained.

“Taylor seems to feel we're living through a revenge comedy right now, so the premise is that [Judy's] taken these three minor characters from Titus the clown, the maid, and the midwife and [Judy]'s named them Gary, Janice, and Carol and they're starring in this so-called sequel,” he continued. “Gary and Janice are assigned the job of cleaning up the aftermath of the Titus Andronicus [mess]. She and I are in a room filled with hundreds and hundreds of dead bodies. The question Taylor is posing is, ‘Why do we always have to clean up the messes that people in power make, and by cleaning them up are we enabling them and enabling history to repeat itself?‘”

The play marks Mac’s Broadway debut and demonstrates his desire to ask tough questions: “The bigger question is, ‘What is the role of the artist in all of this? Can we take all the bad and turn it into something good or in Gary can we take the tragedy and turn it into comedy?'”

Speaking of Broadway debuts, Lane recalled The New Yorker's Brendan Gill raking him over the coals in print for Lane's performance in Present Laughter with George C. Scott: “Then I met him at an American Theater Wing seminar and he told me he was a big fan.”

Gary is currently in previews at Broadway’s Booth Theatre with an official opening scheduled for April 21.

Click Here to Shop for Theatre
Merchandise in the Playbill Store
Latest News

Blocking belongs
on the stage,
not on websites.

Our website is made possible by
displaying online advertisements to our visitors.

Please consider supporting us by
whitelisting playbill.com with your ad blocker.
Thank you!