Wicked proved to be popular among our readers, winning in a landslide against the 2003 revival of Gypsy in the first match-up with 92% of votes. Fans voted for In The Heights over Spring Awakening, with the Lin-Manuel Miranda and Quiara Alegría Hudes musical winning nearly 60% of votes in its match-up. The 2009 revival cast album of West Side Story won against Jersey Boys, with over 70% of the votes. The final match-up, Spamalot against American Idiot, was a tight race, with American Idiot clinching the win with 51% of votes and moving on to the next round.
Click here for details on how the rankings and divisions work.
Voting for Division 2, Round 1 continues through March 25 at 12PM ET.
VOTE FOR THE SHOWS IN DIVISION 2, ROUND 1 BELOW: