The musical has been on the Broadway radar for some time. In 1994, the songwriting duo told Newsday that they hoped to bring the musical to the United States soon. "I would love to see it in this country," Ulvaeus said, "because it's about America, about these people from Sweden going to Minnesota in the 1850s. It's an epic."
The Post article mentioned the possibility of a pre-Broadway tryout in Minneapolis and a Broadway run in spring 2007. Kretzmer told the daily, "We know what needs to be done [with the show], and we shall proceed on the knowledge we've gained."
Andersson and Ulvaeus' other theatre scores include Chess, which has often been mentioned for a return Broadway engagement.
Mamma Mia! continues to pack the Winter Garden Theatre, where it opened in October 2001.