Ferrer premiered in the role on Oct. 8, 1946, at the Alvin (now Neil Simon) Theatre, in what would become an iconic interpretation of the character. New York Times reviewer Brooks Atkinson hailed Ferrer's "pulsating performance" as "rattling good theatre." He won a Tony and later an Academy Award for reprising the role onscreen.
This vintage Playbill from the Playbill Vault archives is dated Nov. 4, 1946, one month into the 193-performance run.