Playbill.com polled our readers via Facebook and Twitter. Their responses follow:

Rachel DeGraffenreid Jeremy Jordan because once upon a time

Catie Moloughney Definitely Jeremy Jordan. His voice just makes me melt. He makes everything sound flawless and effortless. I made the trip up to Boston to see Finding Neverland a few weekends, because I couldn't wait for him to come back to NYC.

Daniel James Devlin Currently - Jeremy Jordan - I mean - that VOICE!

Sidney Dorey Jeremy Jordan!!

Amelia Paas JEREMY JORDAN!!!! ))))

Chris Symon Jeremy Jordan
There is no other
What kind of question is this?!

Caroline Bollinger Jeremy Jordan!

Jeremy Jordan, seen in the pre-Broadway run of Finding Neverland, made his Broadway debut in the 2009 revival of West Side Story as a replacement in the role of Tony. He has also been seen in Bonnie and Clyde, Rock of Ages and Newsies, a performance that earned him a Tony Award nomination. He stars as Jamie in the upcoming film adaptation of Jason Robert Brown's The Last 5 Years, which is slated for a 2015 Valentine's Day release. Check out this clip of Jordan and co-star Anna Kendrick from the movie.

Alyssa Sullivan IDINA Menzel

Robert Poole Lately I've been in the mood for Idina Menzel herself, not sure why...

Rachel Breuer Idina Menzel for sure!!!

Sarah Coradi Idina Menzel

Idina Menzel made her Broadway debut as Maureen in the 1996 production of Jonathan Larson's Pulitzer Prize-winning Rent, a performance that garnered her a Tony nomination for Best Featured Actress in a Musical. She won her Tony for her work in the international hit musical Wicked. Menzel is currently starring in the Tom Kitt and Brian Yorkey musical If/Then, which is playing the Richard Rodgers Theatre. Here is a clip of her Tony-nominated performance.

Blake Sherman Laura Bell Bundy will always be my #WCW

Tony nominee Laura Bell Bundy has been seen on Broadway in Hairspray, Legally Blonde and Wicked.  Check out her Tony-nominated performance as Elle Woods in the filmed-for-television version of Legally Blonde the Musical.

Melissa LaMantia Ramin Karimloo

Jamie Scerbo Ramin Karimloo because he is hot!!! He is amazing as the phantom and valjean!!! His body is perfection!!!

Madison D'Urbano Ramin Karimloo

Nikki Juvan Ramin Karimloo!!!!

Megan Richardson Ramin Karimloo! That voice, that body, that personality! What's not to love ?!

Max Laycock Ramin Karimloo, I'm NOT going to lie.

John Termine Ramin Karimloo!

Connie Francken Cope Ramin!!! Love him.

Amy Reynolds Alexander Ramin..swoon....

Ramin Karimloo made his Broadway debut in the 2014 revival of Les Miserables, earning a Tony nomination for Best Actor in a Musical. He has been seen in London in West End productions of Les Miserables, Phantom of the Opera and Love Never Dies. Check out Seth Rudetsky's episode of "Obsessed" with Karimloo.

Layne Sanders Norm Lewis

Dani Honeyman Norm Lewis- beautiful, rich voice and stage presence. He is an inspirational performer, and his voice brings me great joy.

Tony nominee Norm Lewis is currently starring in the title role of the longest-running Broadway musical, The Phantom of the Opera. Check out this clip of Lewis performing "Bess, You Is My Woman Now" with Audra McDonald from the Tony Award-winning revival of Porgy and Bess.

Shannen Banzhoff The one and only Aaron Tveit!!!

Margaret Daisy Rose AARON TVEIT! Because he is gorgeous, he sings pretty, wonderful amazing actor, and he can clap with one hand. I mean, come on, how many guys do you know that can clap with one hand?

Jennifer Leigh Brown AARON TVEIT<3

Tara Marsh Aaron Tveit, hello?

Amanda Readinger Aaron Tveit. Obviously.

Mona Messmer Aaron Tveit

Marie Gabrielle Bernabe Aaron Tveit!!!! Link, Fiyero, Enjolras, Gabe, Frank Jr. ROGER!!!!!!!!!!! *swoons*

Nikki Sinclair Aaron Tveit. The voice of a thousand tiny angels with the looks to boot! Uber talented. I loved him as Frank and Gabe. He seems like a real sweetheart! Love him in Graceland as well!

Bethany Villarreal Aaron Tveit. The voice of an angel, with the most beautiful note in "I'm Alive"... when I listen to my playlist of his voice, I can't focus on anything. He's also gorgeous.

Aaron Tveit has been seen on Broadway in Hairspray, Wicked, Next to Normal and Catch Me If You Can.  He currently stars on the USA television series "Graceland."  

Suzanne Connell Constantine Maroulis. He has an amazing voice, tremendous stage presence, he's a great actor, so handsome and is so nice to his fans. He is at the stage door after every show.

Judy Yescalis Constantine Maroulis is still the one for me. He can leap creative and vocal boundaries in a heartbeat; from Idol to Brel to Judas or Jekyll, he never disappoints.

RC Rachel Constantine Maroulis! Amazing voice, nicest guy ever, and always has time for his fans
Mimi Shufelt Constantine!

Vicky Welfare I've never seen or heard a Broadway performer that captivated me as much as Constantine Maroulis. Powerhouse voice and powerful presence. You simply can't take your eyes off of him.

Shelly Timperio-Harris Hands down ,no second choice for me Constantine Maroulis!!!

Michelle Marusa Constantine Maroulis!! He can sing with a passion that is unequaled!!! Beautiful voice, fantastic actor and the nicest guy you will ever meet!!!

Lorraine Grabauskas Constantine Maroulis is absolutely mesmerizing, no matter the role he performs. Plus, he spends so much time off stage with fans or for charity, too. That is crush-inducing!

Jackie Schelle Nation Constantine Maroulis

Mary Beth Morris Constantine Maroulis. His acting, his voice, his looks = Triple Threat.

Susan Richmond Belue Constantine!

Cheryl Ann Constantine Maroulis, he entertains me like no one else can.

Constance Anne Constantine- I have seen him in many shows and I get the chills every single time. There is no one like him and a great guy to boot!!!!

Tony Award nominee Constantine Maroulis, an "American Idol" finalist, has been seen on Broadway in The Wedding Singer, Rock of Ages and Jekyll and Hyde. Check out his performance with the cast of Rock of Ages at the 2009 Tony Awards.

Delphine Litke James Snyder. Totally adorable.

Skylar Jeffries James Snyder  He's so amazing and cute.

James Snyder, who was seen in the title role of the musical version of the film Cry-Baby, currently stars opposite Idina Menzel as Josh in the new musical If/Then. Check out this video of Snyder and Elizabeth standby Jackie Burns performing "Here I Go" in Bryant Park.

Maria Commoss Andy Mientus !!! He's so great in Les Mis, his tweets are on point, and have you seen his face?

Chloe Canler Andy Mientus is the cutest person ever

Hunter Emmett Burke Andy Mientus is my Broadway crush. I mean, have you seen him? He's literally one of the most adorable people ever. Plus, he's infinitely talented.

Andy Mientus is currently starring as Marius in the revival of Les Miserables and was also seen in season two of the NBC series "Smash."  Check out this clip of Mientus and the cast of Les Miz performing on "Good Morning America."