Good reviews for Oscar nominee Abigail Breslin ("Little Miss Sunshine") as Helen and Tony Award nominee Alison Pill (The Lieutenant of Inishmore) were not enough to stimulate ticket sales for the period piece about light coming to the darkness of a 19th-century Alabama child who would later inspire generations.
The revival directed by Kate Whoriskey (Ruined) opened at Circle in the Square March 3, placing the famed 1959 drama in-the-round. By close, the production will have played 21 previews and 38 regular performances.
Producers David Richenthal and Dini von Mueffling said in a statement, "We are saddened to announce that The Miracle Worker must close. Having the opportunity to share this powerful story with a new generation of theatergoers has been remarkable. We could not have asked for a more extraordinary cast, creative team and group of dedicated producers."
The producers put out an unusual statement on March 5, saying they would remain open despite soft sales. In a March 5 statement, producer David Richenthal said, "While we are very proud to have received such positive reviews, and overwhelmingly unanimous praise for our leading ladies Abigail Breslin and Alison Pill, the box office has not ignited as we had hoped. But we will continue in good faith with a call to arms for anyone who has been waiting to see it to act now. …If we don’t witness a significant increase in the box office over the weekend we will need to take a close look at our ability to keep the production open."
Breslin stars as Helen Keller in the true story about the angry and chaotic Helen, the blind and deaf Alabama girl who cannot be controlled by her Victorian parents. Enter 20-year-old Annie Sullivan, played by the doll-eyed Pill, the brash Boston teacher who does battle with Helen and brings forth a transformation that helped make Keller an international symbol of overcoming adversity.
Whoriskey (who shepherded Lynn Nottage's Fabulation and Ruined regionally and Off-Broadway) directs the 50th anniversary production. On three different levels on the oval stage of Circle in the Square — Broadway's only in-the-round venue — Annie and Helen violently wrestle in an effort to bring language to the girl's dark world. (Sometimes furniture gets in the way of their feuds, and sometimes not — Whoriskey suspends set pieces from cables and raises and lowers them as needed.)
Annie also fights with the Kellers, who have treated Helen as a kind of "pet." The teacher seeks to break through to the girl by separating her from her overly protective parents and connecting hand signals to objects and people around her.
Set in Alabama in the 1880s, The Miracle Worker, according to production notes, "tells the story of real-life blind and deaf Medal of Freedom winner Helen Keller, who suddenly lost her sight and hearing at the age of 19 months, and the extraordinary teacher who taught her to communicate with the world, Annie Sullivan."
The new Broadway cast of The Miracle Worker also includes Golden Globe and Emmy Award nominee Matthew Modine ("And the Band Played On," "Short Cuts," "Birdy," Hartford Stage's To Kill a Mockingbird) as Capt. Keller; Jennifer Morrison (Fox TV's "House M.D.") as Mrs. Keller; and Tony Award winner Elizabeth Franz (Broadway's Death of a Salesman, Morning's at Seven) as Aunt Ev, with Tobias Segal (The Cherry Orchard at BAM) as Helen's half-brother James, Daniel Oreskes (Billy Elliot) as an Alabama Doctor and Annie's mentor Dr. Anagnos, Michael Cummings (Joe Turner's Come and Gone) as Percy, Simone Joy Jones as Martha, Yvette Ganier (Gem of the Ocean) as Viney and Lance Chantiles-Wertz (The Widowing of Mrs. Holroyd) as the ghost of Annie's brother, Jimmie.
The original 1959 Broadway production famously starred Anne Bancroft as Irish-American Annie and young Patty Duke as Helen. It won six Tony Awards, including Best Play in 1960. They repeated their work for the film version, each winning an Academy Award. Duke later played Annie in a TV film of the work, with Melissa Gilbert as Helen. A theatrical sequel, Monday After the Miracle, also by Gibson, showed Helen and Annie as adults, dealing with very different issues. Gibson died in 2008.
Breslin is most widely known for playing the title role in the film "Little Miss Sunshine," for which she got an Academy Award nomination.
Pill was Tony-nominated for playing a lovestruck Irish terrorist in the dark comedy The Lieutenant of Inishmore.
The producers previously announced that ten-year-old actress Kyra Ynez Siegel, who has vision loss in one of her eyes, has been cast as the understudy to Breslin in the role of Helen.
The Miracle Worker is produced by David Richenthal, Eric Falkenstein, Randall L. Wreghitt, Barbara & Buddy Freitag/Dan Frishwasser, Joseph J. Grano, Jr., Mallory Factor, Cheryl Lachowicz, Martha Falkenberg, Bruce J. Carusi & Susan Altamore Carusi, Lynn Shaw, David & Sheila Lehrer; in association with Connie Bartlow Kristan, Jamie deRoy/Remmel T. Dickinson and associate producers Rosalind Productions, Inc. and Patty Baker/Anna Czekaj.
The creative team includes scenic designer Derek McLane, costume designer Paul Tazewell, lighting designer Kenneth Posner and hair designer Charles LaPointe. Physical coaching and movement is by Lee Sher. Rob Milburn and Michael Bodeen handle original music and sound designer.
Tickets to The Miracle Worker are $117 (including $2 facility charge) and are available by calling Telecharge at (212) 239-6200, visiting www.telecharge.com or visiting Circle in the Square Theatre box office at 235 West 50 Street.
The Miracle Worker plays the following schedule: Tuesday, Wednesday and Thursday at 7 PM; Friday and Saturday at 8 PM; Wednesday and Saturday matinees at 2 PM; Sunday matinees at 3 PM. Dark Monday.
The Miracle Worker is the first Broadway play to offer the D-Scriptive audio system for audience members who are blind or have low vision, as well as the I-Caption system for audience members who are deaf or hard of hearing, both free of charge at every performance.
The show's official website is another Broadway first: it ensures access for all patrons with disabilities.
"Care has been taken to ensure proper contrast in color palettes and choice of typeface to aid users with low vision, and the site functions properly when the design 'style sheets' are deactivated," according to the producers. "This increases usability for patrons who prefer to omit the embedded styling altogether or, alternatively, to use personalized style sheets during their visit."
The production is committed to continually improving the website's accessibility based on feedback from users and partners in the Blind and Deaf communities.