As the ghost with the most sees what shakes loose on Broadway, some cast members of the new musical Beetlejuice have personal experiences to draw from. In the video above, the stars share their own ghoulish encounters and tales from the Netherworld.

Those with particularly strange and unusual anecdotes include Jill Abramovitz (who plays Maxine Dean) and a traumatizing Ouija board experience, Kelvin Moon Loh (Broadway’s Otho) and his vegan paranormal theory, and Tony nominee Rob McClure—who plays a ghost himself as Adam Maitland—who recalls a spooky incident involving Nintendo cartridges.