• 
• Boris Karloff
• James Hook
  Mr. Darling
  

• 
• Jean Arthur
• Peter Pan
  

• 
• Marcia Henderson
• Wendy Moira Angela Darling
  

• 
• Peg Hillias
• Mrs. Darling
  

Replacement

• 
• Joe E. Marks
• Smee
  

• 
• Harry Allen
• Mullins
  

• 
• Stephanie Augustine
• Mermaid
  

• 
• Ronnie Aul
• Big Chief Panther
  

• 
• Lee Barnett
• Tootles
  

• 
• Vincent Beck
• Whibbles
  

• 
• Edward Benjamin
• Second Twin
  

• 
• Charles Brill
• First Twin
  

• 
• Kenneth Davis
• Alf Mason
  Indian
  

• 
• Norman DeJoie
• Indian
  

• 
• John Dennis
• Noodles
  

• 
• Jack Dimond
• John Napoleon Darling
  

• 
• Philip Hepburn
• Curly
  

• 
• Richard Knox
• Slightly
  

• 
• David Kurlan
• Gentleman Starkey
  

• 
• William Marshall
• Cookson
  

• 
• Buzzy Martin
• Nibs
  

• 
• Fred Neal
• Indian
  

• 
• Gloria Patrice
• Liza
  Tiger Lilly
  

• 
• Nehemiah Persoff
• Cecco
  

• 
• Jay Riley
• Flash McCready
  Indian
  

• 
• Will Scholz
• Jukes
  

• 
• Norman Shelley
• Nana
  The Crocodile
  

• 
• William Sumner
• Canary Robb
  Indian
  

• 
• Charles Taylor
• Michael Nicolas Darling
  

• 
• Eleanor Winter
• Mermaid
  

• 
• Stephanie Augustine
• Wendy Moira Angela Darling
  

• 
• Barbara Baxley
• Peter Pan
  

• 
• Vincent Beck
• Mr. Darling
  

• 
• Lucy Hillary
• Mermaid
  Tiger Lilly
  

• 
• William Marshall
• James Hook
  

• 
• Alan Jay Shnapier
• Lost Boy
  

• 
• Kenneth Utt
• Pirate
  

• 
• Eleanor Winter
• Mrs. Darling
  

Replacement

• 
• Trude Rittman
• Musical Coordinator
  

• 
• Ben Steinberg
• Conductor
  

• 
• Gerald Rudy
• Musical Contractor
  

• 
• James M. Barrie
• Writer
  

• 
• Leonard Bernstein
• Music And Lyrics
  

• 
• John Burrell
• Director
  

• 
• Wendy Toye
• Associate Director
  

• 
• Ralph Alswang
• Scenic Design
  Lighting Design
  

• 
• Motley
• Costume Design
  

• 
• Hershy Kay
• Orchestrator
  

• 
• Trude Rittman
• Music Arrangements
  

• 
• Mortimer V. Halpern
• Production Stage Manager
  

• 
• Phil Stein
• Stage Manager
  

• 
• Kenneth Utt
• Assistant Stage Manager
  

• 
• Peter Foy
• Flying Supervisor
  

• 
• Al Goldin
• General Manager
  

• 
• William Fields
• Press Representative
  

• 
• Walter Alford
• Press Representative
  

• 
• Arthur Cantor
• Press Representative
  

• 
• Peter Lawrence
• Producer
  

• 
• Roger L. Stevens
• Producer
  

• 
• The Shubert Organization
• Producer
  

• 
• The Hospital for Sick Children, London - "Peter Pan's Hospital"
• Produced By Arrangement With